<!DOCTYPE html>
<html class="nojs html css_verticalspacer" lang="en-US">
<head>
<meta http-equiv="Content-type" content="text/html;charset=UTF-8"/>
<meta name="generator" content="2017.0.2.363"/>
<meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1.0"/>
<script type="text/javascript">
// Update the 'nojs'/'js' class on the html node
document.documentElement.className = document.documentElement.className.replace(/\bnojs\b/g, 'js');
// Check that all required assets are uploaded and up-to-date
if(typeof Muse == "undefined") window.Muse = {}; window.Muse.assets = {"required":["museutils.js", "museconfig.js", "jquery.musepolyfill.bgsize.js", "jquery.musemenu.js", "jquery.watch.js", "require.js", "cases.css"], "outOfDate":[]};
</script>
<title>Cases</title>
<!-- CSS -->
<link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="css/site_global.css?crc=443350757"/>
<link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="css/master_a-master.css?crc=141232574"/>
<link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="css/cases.css?crc=4133133042" id="pagesheet"/>
<!-- IE-only CSS -->
<!--[if lt IE 9]>
<link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="css/iefonts_cases.css?crc=235910235"/>
<![endif]-->
<!-- Other scripts -->
<script type="text/javascript">
var __adobewebfontsappname__ = "muse";
</script>
<!-- JS includes -->
<script src="https://webfonts.creativecloud.com/actor:n4:default;lato:n4,n7:default.js" type="text/javascript"></script>
<!--[if lt IE 9]>
<script src="scripts/html5shiv.js?crc=4241844378" type="text/javascript"></script>
<![endif]-->
</head>
<body class="museBGSize">
<div class="rgba-background clearfix borderbox" id="page"><!-- column -->
<div class="position_content" id="page_position_content">
<div class="clearfix colelem" id="pu3467"><!-- group -->
<div class="grpelem" id="u3467"><!-- content --></div>
<nav class="MenuBar clearfix grpelem" id="menuu772"><!-- horizontal box -->
<div class="MenuItemContainer clearfix grpelem" id="u773"><!-- vertical box -->
<a class="nonblock nontext MenuItem MenuItemWithSubMenu clearfix colelem" id="u776" href="index.html"><!-- horizontal box --><div class="MenuItemLabel NoWrap clearfix grpelem" id="u779-4"><!-- content --><p>Home</p></div></a>
</div>
<div class="MenuItemContainer clearfix grpelem" id="u3268"><!-- vertical box -->
<a class="nonblock nontext MenuItem MenuItemWithSubMenu clearfix colelem" id="u3269" href="history.html"><!-- horizontal box --><div class="MenuItemLabel NoWrap clearfix grpelem" id="u3270-4"><!-- content --><p>History</p></div></a>
</div>
<div class="MenuItemContainer clearfix grpelem" id="u780"><!-- vertical box -->
<a class="nonblock nontext MenuItem MenuItemWithSubMenu clearfix colelem" id="u783" href="profile.html"><!-- horizontal box --><div class="MenuItemLabel NoWrap clearfix grpelem" id="u784-4"><!-- content --><p>Profile</p></div></a>
</div>
<div class="MenuItemContainer clearfix grpelem" id="u817"><!-- vertical box -->
<a class="nonblock nontext MenuItem MenuItemWithSubMenu clearfix colelem" id="u818" href="public-appointments.html"><!-- horizontal box --><div class="MenuItemLabel NoWrap clearfix grpelem" id="u821-4"><!-- content --><p>Public Appointments</p></div></a>
</div>
<div class="MenuItemContainer clearfix grpelem" id="u859"><!-- vertical box -->
<a class="nonblock nontext MenuItem MenuItemWithSubMenu clearfix colelem" id="u862" href="legal-publication.html"><!-- horizontal box --><div class="MenuItemLabel NoWrap clearfix grpelem" id="u864-4"><!-- content --><p>Legal Publication</p></div></a>
</div>
<div class="MenuItemContainer clearfix grpelem" id="u880"><!-- vertical box -->
<a class="nonblock nontext MenuItem MenuItemWithSubMenu clearfix colelem" id="u883" href="legal-seminars.html"><!-- horizontal box --><div class="MenuItemLabel NoWrap clearfix grpelem" id="u885-4"><!-- content --><p>Legal Seminars</p></div></a>
</div>
<div class="MenuItemContainer clearfix grpelem" id="u901"><!-- vertical box -->
<a class="nonblock nontext MenuItem MenuItemWithSubMenu MuseMenuActive clearfix colelem" id="u904" href="cases.html"><!-- horizontal box --><div class="MenuItemLabel NoWrap clearfix grpelem" id="u906-4"><!-- content --><p>Cases</p></div></a>
</div>
</nav>
<div class="clip_frame grpelem" id="u6790"><!-- svg -->
<img class="svg" id="u6788" src="images/pasted-svg-160117x39.svg?crc=3839381768" alt="" data-mu-svgfallback="images/pasted%20svg%20160117x39_poster_.png?crc=4174989818" data-image-width="160" data-image-height="40"/>
</div>
<a class="nonblock nontext grpelem" id="u4558" href="index.html"><!-- content --></a>
</div>
<div class="clip_frame colelem" id="u1694"><!-- image -->
<img class="block" id="u1694_img" src="images/case_top-crop-u1694.jpg?crc=4080482113" alt="" data-image-width="960" data-image-height="177"/>
</div>
<div class="clearfix colelem" id="pu5750"><!-- group -->
<div class="shadow grpelem" id="u5750"><!-- simple frame --></div>
<a class="nonblock nontext grpelem" id="u5751" href="equitya.html"><!-- rasterized frame --><img id="u5751_img" alt="" src="images/book1-u5751.png?crc=151928463" data-image-width="99"/></a>
<a class="nonblock nontext grpelem" id="u5753" href="equitya.html"><!-- rasterized frame --><img id="u5753_img" alt="" src="images/book2-u5753.png?crc=246054695" data-image-width="99"/></a>
<a class="nonblock nontext grpelem" id="u5755" href="equitya.html"><!-- rasterized frame --><img id="u5755_img" alt="" src="images/book4-u5755.png?crc=4171999532" data-image-width="99"/></a>
<a class="nonblock nontext grpelem" id="u5757" href="equitya.html"><!-- rasterized frame --><img id="u5757_img" alt="" src="images/book3-u5757.png?crc=163390063" data-image-width="99"/></a>
<a class="nonblock nontext grpelem" id="u5759" href="equitya.html"><!-- rasterized frame --><img id="u5759_img" alt="" src="images/book5-u5759.png?crc=338048955" data-image-width="99"/></a>
<a class="nonblock nontext book1 transition shadow clearfix grpelem" id="u5761-5" href="equitya.html"><!-- content --><p id="u5761"> </p><p id="u5761-3">Equity and Trusts Lawin Hong Kong2006</p></a>
<a class="nonblock nontext book1 transition shadow clearfix grpelem" id="u5762-5" href="euqityb.html"><!-- content --><p> </p><p>Equity and Trusts Lawin Hong Kong Second Edition2009</p></a>
<a class="nonblock nontext book1 transition shadow clearfix grpelem" id="u5763-5" href="prinicples.html"><!-- content --><p> </p><p>Principles of Equity &Trusts Law in Hong Kong2009</p></a>
<a class="nonblock nontext book1 transition shadow clearfix grpelem" id="u5764-4" href="halsbury07.html"><!-- content --><p id="u5764-2">Halsbury's Law of HKVol 26(2)Trusts & VoluntaryAssociations2007</p></a>
<a class="nonblock nontext book1 transition shadow clearfix grpelem" id="u5765-4" href="halsbury09.html"><!-- content --><p id="u5765-2">Halsbury's Law of HKVol 26(2)Trusts & VoluntaryAssociations2009</p></a>
<a class="nonblock nontext grpelem" id="u2497" href="mailto:hoyin_hong@iconcept.com.hk"><!-- simple frame --></a>
<div class="shadow rounded-corners clearfix grpelem" id="u4040"><!-- group -->
<div class="rounded-corners grpelem" id="u4043"><!-- simple frame --></div>
<div class="rounded-corners clearfix grpelem" id="u1757-142"><!-- content -->
<p id="u1757-2">Superior Courts Cases</p>
<p id="u1757-3"> </p>
<p id="u1757-5">Administrative & Constitutional Law</p>
<p id="u1757-6"> </p>
<ul class="list0 nls-None" id="u1757-9">
<li id="u1757-8">Cho v Minister of Immigration & Multicultural Affairs (unreported, Federal Court of Australia Emmett J, N652 of 1999, 9 December 1999, BC9908299) [Administrative Law - Refugee - Judicial review of administrative action]</li>
</ul>
<p id="u1757-10"> </p>
<p id="u1757-11"> </p>
<ul class="list0 nls-None" id="u1757-14">
<li id="u1757-13">Re Minister of Immigration & Multicultural Affairs, ex parte Zhou (unreported, High Court of Australia, S73/1999, 21 September 1999) [Constitution - s.75(v) - mandamus and injunction against officer of the Commonwealth]</li>
</ul>
<p id="u1757-15"> </p>
<p id="u1757-16"> </p>
<ul class="list0 nls-None" id="u1757-19">
<li id="u1757-18">Wu v Minister of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Unreported, Federal Magistrates Court, SZ 146 of 2003, Raphael FM, 4 December 2003) [Student Visa - cancellation - failure to satisfy course requirement - insufficient attendance - taking English language course during vacation - whether visa condition applies to an ancillary course which visa not originally issued for - whether MRT incorrectly construed meaning of "semester" in Reg 8202 - whether sufficient particularity provided in Notice of Intention under s.119 - whether supply of relevant information by third party constituted compliance - Minister conceded to have MRT decision set aside - costs awarded]</li>
</ul>
<p id="u1757-20"> </p>
<p id="u1757-21"> </p>
<p id="u1757-22"> </p>
<p id="u1757-24">General Commercial Law</p>
<p id="u1757-25"> </p>
<ul class="list0 nls-None" id="u1757-28">
<li id="u1757-27">Maxims Entertainment Pty Ltd v Chinatown Enterprises Pty Ltd [1999] FCA 1300 (unreported, Federal Court, NG918 of 1995, 9 September 1999, Burchett J, BC9906919) [application to set aside default judgment]</li>
</ul>
<p id="u1757-29"> </p>
<p id="u1757-30"> </p>
<ul class="list0 nls-None" id="u1757-33">
<li id="u1757-32">Yau v Cheung [1999] NSWCA 56 (unreported, Court of Appeal NSW, CA40209/98, 25 March 1999, BC9901067) [Contract - Construction of terms]</li>
</ul>
<p id="u1757-34"> </p>
<p id="u1757-35"> </p>
<ul class="list0 nls-None" id="u1757-38">
<li id="u1757-37">Yau v Cheung (2000) 21(4) Leg Rep SL2a (unreported, High Court of Australia, Gaudron and Gummow JJ, 11 February 2000) [High Court Special Leave application]</li>
</ul>
<p id="u1757-39"> </p>
<p id="u1757-40"> </p>
<ul class="list0 nls-None" id="u1757-43">
<li id="u1757-42">Able King Investments Pty Ltd v Shi (Unreported, Supreme Court of NSW Equity Division, No. 3358 of 2002, 30 August 2002) [Statutory Demand - Setting Aside - Genuine Dispute as to existence of debt]</li>
</ul>
<p id="u1757-44"> </p>
<p id="u1757-45"> </p>
<ul class="list0 nls-None" id="u1757-48">
<li id="u1757-47">TMB Pty Ltd v Symak 2 Holdings Pty Ltd (Unreported, Supreme Court of NSW Equity Division, Austin J, No. 1139 of 2003) [Vendor and Purchaser - Recovery of deposit - Consent judgment - Enforcement of judgment in United States]</li>
</ul>
<p id="u1757-49"> </p>
<p id="u1757-50"> </p>
<ul class="list0 nls-None" id="u1757-53">
<li id="u1757-52">Ginger Development Enterprises Pty Ltd v Crown Developments Australia Pty Ltd [2003] NSWCA 296 (Unreported, Court of Appeal, Supreme Court of NSW, Mason P, Sheller JA, Davies AJA, 16 October 2003) [Vendor and Purchaser - Sale of land - whether vendor had right to rescind]</li>
</ul>
<p id="u1757-54"> </p>
<p id="u1757-55"> </p>
<ul class="list0 nls-None" id="u1757-58">
<li id="u1757-57">Prakash v Wang (Unreported, Supreme Court of NSW, Equity Division, Young CJ in Eq, No. 5640 of 2003) [Contract for sale of land - Husband and Wife joint tenancy - Husband alone signed contract - contract exchanged pending settlement - caveat lodged by purchaser - whether caveat should be discharged]</li>
</ul>
<p id="u1757-59"> </p>
<p id="u1757-60"> </p>
<p id="u1757-62">Practice and Civil Procedure</p>
<p id="u1757-63"> </p>
<ul class="list0 nls-None" id="u1757-66">
<li id="u1757-65">Csalar v Circosta (2002) 55 NSWLR 212; [2002] NSWSC 482 (Supreme Court of NSW, O'Keefe J, No. SC 11672 of 2001, 31 May 2002) [Statutory interpretation - appeal against Magistrates decision - error of law] - R</li>
</ul>
<p id="u1757-67"> </p>
<p id="u1757-68"> </p>
<ul class="list0 nls-None" id="u1757-71">
<li id="u1757-70">Australian Guangzhou Association Incorporated v Huang (Supreme Court of NSW, McLaughlin M. No. 5278 of 2001, 6 December 2001) [Challenging a solicitor's retainer - indemnity costs]</li>
</ul>
<p id="u1757-72"> </p>
<p id="u1757-73"> </p>
<ul class="list0 nls-None" id="u1757-76">
<li id="u1757-75">AIMS Home Loans Pty Ltd v Luo (Unreported, Supreme Court of NSW, Equity Division, No. 3816 of 2003, Bryson J, 11 September 2003)</li>
</ul>
<p id="u1757-77"> </p>
<p id="u1757-78"> </p>
<p id="u1757-79"> </p>
<p id="u1757-81">Company Law</p>
<p id="u1757-82"> </p>
<ul class="list0 nls-None" id="u1757-85">
<li id="u1757-84">Tranzlink International Pty Ltd v Chinese Products Exhibition & Marketing Pty Ltd [2000] NSWSC 200(unreported, Supreme Court of NSW, Master MacCready, 6 March 2000, 4704/1999, BC200001127) [Corporations - Winding up - Presumption of insolvency - Test of Insolvency]</li>
</ul>
<p id="u1757-86"> </p>
<p id="u1757-87"> </p>
<ul class="list0 nls-None" id="u1757-90">
<li id="u1757-89">Global Knitwear v Luois [2001] NSWSC 556 (Supreme Court of NSW, Macready M, No. 1925 of 2001, 19 June 2001) [Corporations - Setting aside statutory demand - Genuine offsetting claim]</li>
</ul>
<p id="u1757-91"> </p>
<p id="u1757-92"> </p>
<ul class="list0 nls-None" id="u1757-95">
<li id="u1757-94">Tseng v Ricketts (Unreported, Supreme Court of NSW Equity Division, Bryson J, No1417 of 2002, 15 February 2002) [Corporations - Winding Up - Just & Equitable Ground - Deadlock in management]</li>
</ul>
<p id="u1757-96"> </p>
<p id="u1757-97"> </p>
<ul class="list0 nls-None" id="u1757-100">
<li id="u1757-99">Tang v Chui (Unreported, Supreme Court of NSW Equity Division, Austin J, No. 4740 of 2001, 28 October 2002) [Corporations - Winding Up - Just & Equitable Ground - Breakdown of mutual trust and confidence]</li>
</ul>
<p id="u1757-101"> </p>
<p id="u1757-102"> </p>
<ul class="list0 nls-None" id="u1757-105">
<li id="u1757-104">All Reach Travel Pty Limited v China Business Focus Pty Limited [2004] NSWSC 211 (unreported, Campbell J, Supreme Court of NSW Equity Division Corporations List, SC 5884 of 2003, 22 March 2004) [Corporations - winding up - application to terminate winding up - proper applicant - need for proof of solvency - if all debts not paid out, need for independent accountant's report on solvency - if debts paid out with money contributed, need to have money contributed in form of capital]</li>
</ul>
<p id="u1757-106"> </p>
<p id="u1757-107"> </p>
<ul class="list0 nls-None" id="u1757-110">
<li id="u1757-109">All Reach Travel Pty Limited v China Business Focus Pty Limited (unreported, Barrett J, Supreme Court of NSW Equity Division Corporations List, SC 5884 of 2003, 10 May 2004)</li>
</ul>
<p id="u1757-111"> </p>
<p id="u1757-112"> </p>
<p id="u1757-113"> </p>
<p id="u1757-115">Equity and Trust</p>
<p id="u1757-116"> </p>
<ul class="list0 nls-None" id="u1757-119">
<li id="u1757-118">Chiou v Wang [2000] FCA 713 (unreported, Federal Court of Australia, Q28 / 2000, Drummond J, 29 May 2000, BC200003643) [Mareva injunction application restraining dissipation of assets]</li>
</ul>
<p id="u1757-120"> </p>
<p id="u1757-121"> </p>
<ul class="list0 nls-None" id="u1757-124">
<li id="u1757-123">Chiou v Wang [2000] QSC 251 (unreported, Supreme Court of Queensland, 4933 / 2000, Muir J, 20 June 2000, BC200004556) [Mareva injunction application restraining dissipation of assets]</li>
</ul>
<p id="u1757-125"> </p>
<p id="u1757-126"> </p>
<ul class="list0 nls-None" id="u1757-129">
<li id="u1757-128">Asia Television Ltd v Oscar Video Club Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 1377; BC200105921 Drummond J Federal Court 21 September 2001[Ex parte Anton Piller Order Application]</li>
</ul>
<p id="u1757-130"> </p>
<p id="u1757-131"> </p>
<ul class="list0 nls-None" id="u1757-134">
<li id="u1757-133">Ge v Pan (unreported, Family Court, Sydney Registry, Loughnan JR, SYF 2615 of 2005, 11 August 2005) [Family Law - property settlement - injunction - exercise of discretion - whether family court should restrain the director husband in a family company]</li>
</ul>
<p id="u1757-135"> </p>
<p id="u1757-136"> </p>
<p id="u1757-137"> </p>
<p id="u1757-138"> </p>
<p id="u1757-139"> </p>
<p id="u1757-140"> </p>
</div>
</div>
</div>
<div class="verticalspacer" data-offset-top="3058" data-content-above-spacer="2971" data-content-below-spacer="211"></div>
<div class="clearfix colelem" id="pu5819"><!-- group -->
<div class="clip_frame clearfix grpelem" id="u5819"><!-- image -->
<img class="position_content" id="u5819_img" src="images/nav_backgorund.jpg?crc=154383802" alt="" width="960" height="707"/>
</div>
<div class="clearfix grpelem" id="u468-8"><!-- content -->
<p>Copyright © 2016 by Lawrence Ma. All rights reserved.</p>
<p>You may reproduce materials available at this site for personal and educational use and for non-commercial distribution.</p>
<p>All copies must include the above copyright notice. The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice.</p>
</div>
<div class="clip_frame grpelem" id="u3196"><!-- image -->
<img class="block" id="u3196_img" src="images/tel-01.png?crc=4083164963" alt="" width="36" height="38"/>
</div>
<div class="clip_frame grpelem" id="u3206"><!-- image -->
<img class="block" id="u3206_img" src="images/gmail-01.png?crc=289476978" alt="" width="36" height="38"/>
</div>
<div class="clip_frame grpelem" id="u6746"><!-- image -->
<img class="block" id="u6746_img" src="images/location.png?crc=3772611778" alt="" width="36" height="38"/>
</div>
<div class="clearfix grpelem" id="u3226-4"><!-- content -->
<p>+852 3173 5511</p>
</div>
<div class="clearfix grpelem" id="u3229-4"><!-- content -->
<p>ma@leagcounsel.com.hk</p>
</div>
<div class="clearfix grpelem" id="u3235-6"><!-- content -->
<p>16C Neich Tower 128 Gloucester Road</p>
<p>Wanchai Hong Kong</p>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</div>
<!-- Other scripts -->
<script type="text/javascript">
window.Muse.assets.check=function(d){if(!window.Muse.assets.checked){window.Muse.assets.checked=!0;var b={},c=function(a,b){if(window.getComputedStyle){var c=window.getComputedStyle(a,null);return c&&c.getPropertyValue(b)||c&&c[b]||""}if(document.documentElement.currentStyle)return(c=a.currentStyle)&&c[b]||a.style&&a.style[b]||"";return""},a=function(a){if(a.match(/^rgb/))return a=a.replace(/\s+/g,"").match(/([\d\,]+)/gi)[0].split(","),(parseInt(a[0])<<16)+(parseInt(a[1])<<8)+parseInt(a[2]);if(a.match(/^\#/))return parseInt(a.substr(1),
16);return 0},g=function(g){for(var f=document.getElementsByTagName("link"),h=0;h<f.length;h++)if("text/css"==f[h].type){var i=(f[h].href||"").match(/\/?css\/([\w\-]+\.css)\?crc=(\d+)/);if(!i||!i[1]||!i[2])break;b[i[1]]=i[2]}f=document.createElement("div");f.className="version";f.style.cssText="display:none; width:1px; height:1px;";document.getElementsByTagName("body")[0].appendChild(f);for(h=0;h<Muse.assets.required.length;){var i=Muse.assets.required[h],l=i.match(/([\w\-\.]+)\.(\w+)$/),k=l&&l[1]?
l[1]:null,l=l&&l[2]?l[2]:null;switch(l.toLowerCase()){case "css":k=k.replace(/\W/gi,"_").replace(/^([^a-z])/gi,"_$1");f.className+=" "+k;k=a(c(f,"color"));l=a(c(f,"backgroundColor"));k!=0||l!=0?(Muse.assets.required.splice(h,1),"undefined"!=typeof b[i]&&(k!=b[i]>>>24||l!=(b[i]&16777215))&&Muse.assets.outOfDate.push(i)):h++;f.className="version";break;case "js":h++;break;default:throw Error("Unsupported file type: "+l);}}d?d().jquery!="1.8.3"&&Muse.assets.outOfDate.push("jquery-1.8.3.min.js"):Muse.assets.required.push("jquery-1.8.3.min.js");
f.parentNode.removeChild(f);if(Muse.assets.outOfDate.length||Muse.assets.required.length)f="Some files on the server may be missing or incorrect. Clear browser cache and try again. If the problem persists please contact website author.",g&&Muse.assets.outOfDate.length&&(f+="\nOut of date: "+Muse.assets.outOfDate.join(",")),g&&Muse.assets.required.length&&(f+="\nMissing: "+Muse.assets.required.join(",")),alert(f)};location&&location.search&&location.search.match&&location.search.match(/muse_debug/gi)?setTimeout(function(){g(!0)},5E3):g()}};
var muse_init=function(){require.config({baseUrl:""});require(["jquery","museutils","whatinput","jquery.musemenu","jquery.musepolyfill.bgsize","jquery.watch"],function(d){var $ = d;$(document).ready(function(){try{
window.Muse.assets.check($);/* body */
Muse.Utils.transformMarkupToFixBrowserProblemsPreInit();/* body */
Muse.Utils.prepHyperlinks(true);/* body */
Muse.Utils.fullPage('#page');/* 100% height page */
Muse.Utils.initWidget('.MenuBar', ['#bp_infinity'], function(elem) { return $(elem).museMenu(); });/* unifiedNavBar */
Muse.Utils.showWidgetsWhenReady();/* body */
Muse.Utils.transformMarkupToFixBrowserProblems();/* body */
}catch(b){if(b&&"function"==typeof b.notify?b.notify():Muse.Assert.fail("Error calling selector function: "+b),false)throw b;}})})};
</script>
<!-- RequireJS script -->
<script src="scripts/require.js?crc=4234670167" type="text/javascript" async data-main="scripts/museconfig.js?crc=4152223963" onload="if (requirejs) requirejs.onError = function(requireType, requireModule) { if (requireType && requireType.toString && requireType.toString().indexOf && 0 <= requireType.toString().indexOf('#scripterror')) window.Muse.assets.check(); }" onerror="window.Muse.assets.check();"></script>
</body>
</html>